206. Public outreach begins only after a stranger has finished a first task unaided
Kontext
On 2026-10-12 the owner asked whether the project was ready for LinkedIn and early adopters. The answer found no independent evidence that a foreign developer can understand, install and keep using it, and the owner ordered a beta first. The definition given was narrow: a reliable, repeatable product a stranger uses without the maintainer, not the whole roadmap. Since then the alpha (v1.0.0-alpha.1) was set for 2026-10-19 under Operation Convergence, but at 707a04c7ce8 neither decision is a tracked intent or ADR on master.
Rozhodnutí
No public invitation to try Majordomus is made while intent a-stranger-adopts-it-unaided is unsatisfied. Readiness is the intent's derived verdict, not a feeling or a backlog count; what counts as a stranger's run is defined by the outside-first-run workflow; a release label (alpha, beta) does not by itself permit outreach. A private, consented invitation of named individual testers to make an outside first run is not public outreach and is permitted; only a public invitation waits on the verdict.
Zamítnuté alternativy
- Immediate launch on the feature inventory
- Waiting for the whole roadmap, the mesh and the intent engine
- Driving the backlog to zero as the readiness measure
Důsledky
The owner keeps the decision of when and where to announce; the repository supplies a verdict. Outreach work (posts, communities) waits; adoption work (time-to-first-refusal, init findings, outside runs) is prioritised after the alpha.
Sources
Promoted on 2026-10-18 from the owner's ChatGPT project (workspace chatgpt-majordomus, issue I3100). The owner's acceptance is at chatgpt-majordomus:c241#3; accepting this record is still the owner's act.
chatgpt-majordomus:c241#0chatgpt-majordomus:c241#3chatgpt-majordomus:c241#4chatgpt-majordomus:c137#2