I3085 — An article explains how a doubt is settled in both languages: by an experiment, not a count
Publish site/content-src/a-doubt-is-settled-by-an-experiment.md, an English article on how a session settles a material engineering uncertainty (ADR 0098). It covers why a decision made silently cannot be audited and why advice pasted into a chat is lost, the assessment and the evidence its writer requires, the review budget a policy computes, advisors as optional capabilities whose absence is state, the structured local review, a disagreement settled by an experiment and never by a count, the conclusion whose review count is computed, how the records reach the next session, and what the protocol does not do. Its example is the doubt weighed on 2026-10-21 that docs/RELEASE.md records. Every statement is one that ADR 0098, rules project.advisors-are-optional and project.review-is-recorded-not-claimed, docs/REASONING.md, docs/RELEASE.md or the reasoning code on master states, and no count is typed by hand. site/content-src/pochybnost-rozhodne-experiment.md is its Czech translation, naming translated_from and its source's digest. site/data/nav.toml lists both. Both relate the plan-critique, continuity and mesh articles, each of which names them back in its own language.
BLOKOVÁNO vlna 10 · p2 · implementační profil · bezpečné paralelně
Součást public-proof — Návštěvník vidí, jak se produkt sám dokazuje, a může ověřit každé jeho tvrzení.
Blocked. This issue cannot start until I3084, I3076 are done. The status is derived from that, not declared.
Cíl
Publish site/content-src/a-doubt-is-settled-by-an-experiment.md, an English article on how a session settles a material engineering uncertainty (ADR 0098). It covers why a decision made silently cannot be audited and why advice pasted into a chat is lost, the assessment and the evidence its writer requires, the review budget a policy computes, advisors as optional capabilities whose absence is state, the structured local review, a disagreement settled by an experiment and never by a count, the conclusion whose review count is computed, how the records reach the next session, and what the protocol does not do. Its example is the doubt weighed on 2026-10-21 that docs/RELEASE.md records. Every statement is one that ADR 0098, rules project.advisors-are-optional and project.review-is-recorded-not-claimed, docs/REASONING.md, docs/RELEASE.md or the reasoning code on master states, and no count is typed by hand. site/content-src/pochybnost-rozhodne-experiment.md is its Czech translation, naming translated_from and its source's digest. site/data/nav.toml lists both. Both relate the plan-critique, continuity and mesh articles, each of which names them back in its own language.
Proč
The owner asked on 2026-10-19 that the site's articles be developed and interlinked in every language. How a session decides under uncertainty, with evidence first and advisors optional, was explained only in docs/REASONING.md and ADR 0098, which are written for the sessions that follow them.
Aktuální stav
No article explains how a doubt is settled. The article groups relate each other, and none of them names it.
Cílový stav
/a-doubt-is-settled-by-an-experiment/ and /pochybnost-rozhodne-experiment/ are built, are counterparts of each other, are listed in the navigation, and are related both ways with three other groups. Check 21 passes, with the translation at its source's digest.
Rozsah
- .ai/repo/project/issues/I3085.yaml
- site/content-src/a-doubt-is-settled-by-an-experiment.md
- site/content-src/pochybnost-rozhodne-experiment.md
- site/content-src/a-plan-is-attacked-before-it-is-built.md
- site/content-src/plan-se-napadne-driv-nez-se-postavi.md
- site/content-src/a-session-ends-the-work-does-not.md
- site/content-src/session-skonci-prace-ne.md
- site/content-src/many-machines-one-journal.md
- site/content-src/mnoho-stroju-jeden-denik.md
- site/data/nav.toml
- scripts/ci/english-only-allow.txt
Mimo rozsah
- Changing the reasoning protocol, its policy, its records or the ADR and rules the article explains
Závislosti
- I3084READY An article explains the mesh in both languages: many machines, one journal
- I3076BLOCKED The landing clock's first source is measured, a fresh clone's wait is a labelled bound, and case 3470 shows a decided version
Co na tom čeká
Kritéria přijetí
- Both articles are built, declare each other in [extra.translations], and the Czech one records translated_from = a-doubt-is-settled-by-an-experiment/ and the digest check 21 computes of its source
- Each statement is one a record, manual or the reasoning code on master states, and check 19 finds no count typed by hand
- scripts/site-check --articles passes the tree, counting the new related links
Validace
- majordomus plan validate
- scripts/site-check --articles site/content-src site/data/nav.toml site/config.toml
- env -u MAJORDOMUS_SHARE -u MAJORDOMUS_HTTP_HOST -u MJ_ROOT bash test/run.sh 3389_related_articles_answer_each_other_in_every_language
Důkazy
Nic nezaznamenáno. Za každým tokenem výše musí stát příkaz nebo artefakt, než lze tento úkol dokončit; vyprávění se odmítá.
Časová osa
- zahájeno
- —
- ověřeno
- —
- dokončeno
- —
Tato tři pole, důkazy výše a stav závislostí jsou vše, z čeho se stav skládá. Neexistuje žádné pole stavu, které by s nimi mohlo být v rozporu.
Canonical record: .ai/repo/project/issues/I3085.yaml. Read it back with majordomus plan show I3085.