I3162 — Which task.refused lines are friction is measured across every checkout, and then each repeated refused rule becomes one observation candidate

○PŘIPRAVENO wave 0 · p2 · deep-work profile · parallel safe

Part of knowledge-acts-on-what-it-learns — The repository decides when to evolve its layer, and a session carries it out.

Cíl

Measure once, over every checkout's ledger, which refusals are friction rather than the tool working, and record the classification rule through majordomus reasoning; then have the deriver, reading only the closing checkout's ledger across its episodes, turn a refused rule id seen in at least a declared number of episodes into one observation candidate with about and route.

Proč

Intent a-session-leaves-what-it-observed puts friction from task.refused/task.gate out of scope until measured; the 2026-10-16 evolve design asked for repeated failure and repeated manual intervention as signals. Critique 2026-10-18 measured 2 task.refused lines in the primary ledger, 127 task.refused lines and 1 task.gate line across the 443 worktree ledgers. It also corrected the current_state: lib/history.sh:158 reads task.refused for display, but no deriver reads it, and master has four curated notes, not five. Sources: chatgpt-majordomus:c274#2.

Aktuální stav

mj_knowledge_evidence maps decisions, resolved questions, finished tasks and observation.recorded; task.refused is written and lib/history.sh reads it for display, but no deriver reads it; task.gate is written only by `majordomus gate record`.

Cílový stav

A recorded measurement and a policy-declared threshold.

Rozsah

• lib/knowledge.sh
• .ai/repo/policy.yaml
• docs/KNOWLEDGE.md
• share/schemas/majordomus/policy/policy.v1.schema.json
• share/skeleton/policy.yaml
• share/allow/policy.txt
• .ai/repo/project/intents

Mimo rozsah

• Classifying with a model
• Deriving friction from task.gate
• Reading another checkout's ledger from the deriver

Závislosti

Žádné. Tento úkol je kořenem grafu.

Co na tom čeká

• I3164✕BLOCKED A change an evolve run makes yields no candidate about itself, and a rejected subject is not proposed again without new evidence

Kritéria přijetí

• The measurement is recorded with its denominator
• A refused rule id seen in N episodes of the closing checkout yields one candidate citing every episode
• Each new case named here takes its number from `scripts/case-numbers next` and is announced on the board before the file is written (ADR 0053); a case number written in this record before that is provisional
• The measurement is a one-time read of every checkout's ledger (the primary and each <repository>-wt worktree), recorded through majordomus reasoning with per-checkout counts and the denominator (episodes and finish calls per checkout)
• The deriver reads only the closing checkout's own ledger, across its episodes; that read writes nothing, and the deriver still writes only the closing episode's candidate file, which keeps the parent invariant
• A friction candidate cites only references that resolve in every checkout (task ids, issue ids, refused rule ids, commits), never a checkout-local episode or session id, so a committed friction candidate passes doctor in another checkout (adopter report #20)
• The subject of a refusal is each rule id in task.refused's refused[], routed as mj_knowledge_route routes it (majordomus.* to platform, project.* to the repository); the measurement records, per class, whether a refusal is friction or the tool working
• task.gate is not a deriver source; the measurement reports its count and the reason it is rare (only `majordomus gate record` writes it, and it keys on 'task', not 'task_id')
• The friction threshold is an optional policy key with a default, declared in the policy schema and skeleton; doctor passes on a policy without it
• The criterion friction-is-measured-first is rewritten to evidence: test with the allocated case path, and that case runs in this issue's validation

Validace

• bash test/run.sh 981_an_observation_becomes_a_grouped_candidate

Požadované důkazy

• case_friction_becomes_a_candidate

Důkazy

Nic nezaznamenáno. Za každým tokenem výše musí stát příkaz nebo artefakt, než lze tento úkol dokončit; vyprávění se odmítá.

Časová osa

zahájeno

—

ověřeno

—

dokončeno

—

Tato tři pole, důkazy výše a stav závislostí jsou vše, z čeho se stav skládá. Neexistuje žádné pole stavu, které by s nimi mohlo být v rozporu.

Canonical record: .ai/repo/project/issues/I3162.yaml. Read it back with majordomus plan show I3162.