Keep every provider bootstrap thin, generated and within budget

setup: installed-wired
given:
  - 'installed, and the two enforcements the policy declares are actually in place as hooks'
steps:
  - id: generate
    run: ['update']
    note: 'every projection the policy names, from the one policy, deterministically'
    expect:
      exit: 0
      stdout_contains: ['AGENTS.md', 'CLAUDE.md', 'each carries its own stamp']
  - id: prove
    run: ['doctor']
    note: 'each projection matches its stamp, points at .ai/README.md, carries no rule of its own, stays under budget, and every reference in it resolves'
    expect:
      exit: 0
      stdout_contains: ['^OK   projection', '^OK   bootstrap', '^OK   budget', '^OK   links', '^OK   counts', 'doctor: 0 failure']
  - id: quiet
    run: ['watch']
    note: 'nothing has drifted since the generation'
    expect:
      exit: 0
      stdout_contains: ['0 drift finding']
then:
  - 'each generated file carries the policy hash and its own content hash'
  - 'the always-loaded file is under the policy’s line budget'
  - 'a hardcoded count or a dangling reference in it would have failed doctor'

The scenario

Executed against the real tool, in a repository prepared by installed-wired, every time this site is generated. What follows is not a description of what should happen; it is what happened.

What the tool did

Evidence of the run this page was generated from: pass, 3 step(s). Output is normalised: the repository's path, timestamps, ids and durations are placeholders; nothing else is edited.

Tested by test/cases/94_use_cases.sh, which runs every scenario and refuses a step whose recorded output is not what it produced.

1. 1$ majordomus update exit 0

   every projection the policy names, from the one policy, deterministically

   unchanged AGENTS.md
   unchanged CLAUDE.md
   unchanged GEMINI.md
   generated 3 target(s) from policy 1791d4f72c77; each carries its own stamp

   • exit 0
   • stdout_contains /AGENTS.md/
   • stdout_contains /CLAUDE.md/
   • stdout_contains /each carries its own stamp/
2. 2$ majordomus doctor exit 0

   each projection matches its stamp, points at .ai/README.md, carries no rule of its own, stays under budget, and every reference in it resolves

   OK   knowledge   graph — buildable here: 100 node(s), 58 edge(s), compiled into a temporary file and removed; no stored index to go stale
   OK   knowledge   records — 0 record(s) valid against knowledge/v1; every reference resolves  [reproduce: majordomus knowledge check]
   OK   knowledge   candidates — 0 await review, cap 40
   OK   layout      .ai/manifest.yaml — schema ai-repository/v1
   OK   layout      .ai/repo/scope.yaml — version 1; 14 in pathspec(s); every key is one the schema declares
   OK   layout      .ai/local/ — ignored, and nothing under it is tracked
   OK   layout      .ai/ — every section the manifest names exists; the layer is readable without the tool
   OK   layout      .ai/repo/prompts — present
   OK   layout      .ai/local/state/handovers — present, 0 record(s)
   OK   layout      .ai/local/state/checkpoints — present, 0 record(s)
   OK   records     ledger.jsonl — every line is a well-formed event
   OK   policy      39 key(s) — every policy value the code reads is declared, with no reader-side default
   OK   bootstrap   3 projection(s) — each points at .ai/README.md, carries no rule of its own and names only rules in force
   OK   catalogue   0 use case(s), 0 application(s) — every command, doctrine, claim, responsibility, category, setup and cross-reference resolves, both directions
   OK   context     .ai/ — 20 context document(s) carry the contract; ids unique, references resolve, no final document superseded, no cycle  [reproduce: majordomus context validate]
   OK   policy      .ai/repo/policy.yaml — parsed, version 1
   OK   profiles    4 files — parsed; default 'implementation' exists
   INFO adr         .ai/repo/adrs/ — no decisions; nothing to validate
   OK   records     decisions.md — every entry is attributable
   INFO project     .ai/repo/project — no canonical project model here; nothing to validate
   OK   command     surface — 30 public command(s), reconciled against the dispatch table  [reproduce: majordomus doctor]
   OK   doctrine    50 of 61 rule(s) carry a validator — validator, dispatch, propagation, test and CI resolve for every one of the 50; the remaining 11 declare no validator and this check does not examine them
   OK   wiring      doctor-on-commit — wired via .githooks/pre-commit
   OK   wiring      finish-on-push — wired via .githooks/pre-push
   OK   command     coverage — every public command is exercised and refuted  [reproduce: bash test/run.sh 31_command_coverage]
   OK   resolver    handovers — no record for this worktree and branch (absence, not a stale match)  [reproduce: majordomus handover --resolve]
   OK   lifecycle   activity — 0 episode(s) opened here; too few to judge whether the writers stopped
   OK   knowledge   wiring — the close path and the compaction adapter call the deriver
   OK   knowledge   deriver — no episode has closed here; nothing to judge
   INFO project     .ai/repo/project — no canonical project model here; nothing to validate
   OK   projection  AGENTS.md — content matches its stamp
   OK   projection  CLAUDE.md — content matches its stamp
   OK   projection  GEMINI.md — content matches its stamp
   OK   budget      AGENTS.md — 42 lines, budget 150
   OK   links       AGENTS.md — all references resolve
   OK   counts      AGENTS.md — no hardcoded counts
   OK   context     builder — 21 lines, budget 300  [reproduce: majordomus context]
   OK   capture     share/schemas/majordomus/capture/capture.v1 — 2 file(s) describe majordomus.capture/v1 at the path the identifier derives: the record as JSON Schema, the document as protobuf
   OK   capture     .ai/local/prompts — ignored and untracked
   OK   capture     .ai/local/prompts — no records yet; the archive is empty
   OK   capture     .ai/local/prompts — every prompt is present as all three: the record, the Markdown and the YAML
   OK   prompts     .ai/local/prompts — the archive and every record in it are readable by their owner only
   OK   prompts     .ai/local/prompts — no records yet; the archive is empty
   OK   prompt      4 asset(s) — front matter valid, every token known
   OK   records     open-questions.md — every entry parses
   OK   retention   ledger — 2 lines, cap 5000
   OK   retention   handovers — 0 files, cap 200
   OK   retention   checkpoints — 0 files, cap 500
   OK   retention   sessions — 0 records, cap 500
   INFO project     .ai/repo/project — no canonical project model here; nothing to validate
   OK   rules       .ai/repo/rules/vendor/majordomus — every file matches the manifest (1 (1.0.0-alpha.8))
   OK   rules       61 rule(s) — resolve in one deterministic order; vendored baseline plus project rules, no override — 51 carry a validator, 10 are normative text this tool does not check
   OK   rules       blocking — all 44 blocking rule(s) carry a validator
   OK   schema      rules — 61 rule(s) resolve in one order: the vendored baseline in manifest order, then the project's, as a dependency graph
   OK   schema      share/kinds.yaml — 37 kind(s); every one that carries metadata declares a schema
   OK   schema      share/schemas — 54 schema(s), each valid JSON and each applied — by a kind, through an allow-list the tool reads, by a validator that names it, or as a generated document's contract (15)
   OK   records     0 record(s) — every changed_files names work, not generated or local state
   OK   session     .ai/local/session-contexts — ignored and untracked
   OK   session     .ai/local/session-contexts — no working contexts yet; the store is empty
   INFO skill       .ai/repo/skills/ — no skills; nothing to validate
   OK   skill       reachable — no personal command or skill shares a name with a projected skill  [reproduce: majordomus run editors.status]
   INFO use-case    30 advisory gap(s) — not covered by an active use case, and the policy does not require it: command:init command:update command:doctor command:watch command:start command:context command:checkpoint command:handover command:check command:finish command:history command:decision command:question command:prompt command:evidence command:skills command:capture command:search command:doctrine command:plan command:version command:session command:knowledge command:adr command:usecase command:rules command:migrate command:recover command:bench command:archive  [reproduce: majordomus usecase coverage]
   OK   use-case    0 of 30 target(s) covered — every public command the policy requires is named and run by an active use case (policy use_cases.coverage)
   INFO env         - — bash <version>, git <version>, jq <version>, shellcheck present
   WARN clone       unpushed — commits on no remote: main(2) — work on one disk is invisible to every other session and cannot be integrated  [reproduce: git push -u origin <branch>]
   OK   clone       uncommitted — no linked worktree, so no uncommitted work can sit in one
   INFO clone       trunk — no remote-tracking branch, so this checkout's distance from the remote trunk cannot be measured
   INFO clone       release — no remote-tracking branch, so whether the trunk's landed work is released cannot be measured
   ·    reasoning   <decided by the advisors and the executable of the recording machine>
   ·    layout      - — <judged when the recording machine has built the executable>
   ·    budget      doctor — <timed against the policy budget>
   doctor: 0 failure(s)

   • exit 0
   • stdout_contains /^OK projection/
   • stdout_contains /^OK bootstrap/
   • stdout_contains /^OK budget/
   • stdout_contains /^OK links/
   • stdout_contains /^OK counts/
   • stdout_contains /doctor: 0 failure/
3. 3$ majordomus watch exit 0

   nothing has drifted since the generation

   OK   knowledge   graph — buildable here: 100 node(s), 58 edge(s), compiled into a temporary file and removed; no stored index to go stale
   OK   layout      .ai/manifest.yaml — schema ai-repository/v1
   OK   layout      .ai/repo/scope.yaml — version 1; 14 in pathspec(s); every key is one the schema declares
   OK   layout      .ai/local/ — ignored, and nothing under it is tracked
   OK   layout      .ai/ — every section the manifest names exists; the layer is readable without the tool
   INFO checkpoint  - — no active task
   OK   records     ledger.jsonl — every line is a well-formed event
   OK   policy      39 key(s) — every policy value the code reads is declared, with no reader-side default
   OK   bootstrap   3 projection(s) — each points at .ai/README.md, carries no rule of its own and names only rules in force
   OK   catalogue   0 use case(s), 0 application(s) — every command, doctrine, claim, responsibility, category, setup and cross-reference resolves, both directions
   OK   context     .ai/ — 20 context document(s) carry the contract; ids unique, references resolve, no final document superseded, no cycle  [reproduce: majordomus context validate]
   OK   policy      policy+profiles — match the last update (<hash12>)
   INFO adr         .ai/repo/adrs/ — no decisions; nothing to validate
   OK   records     decisions.md — every entry is attributable
   INFO project     .ai/repo/project — no canonical project model here; nothing to validate
   OK   command     surface — 30 public command(s), reconciled against the dispatch table  [reproduce: majordomus doctor]
   OK   command     coverage — every public command is exercised and refuted  [reproduce: bash test/run.sh 31_command_coverage]
   OK   resolver    handovers — no record for this worktree and branch (absence, not a stale match)  [reproduce: majordomus handover --resolve]
   OK   lifecycle   activity — 0 episode(s) opened here; too few to judge whether the writers stopped
   OK   knowledge   wiring — the close path and the compaction adapter call the deriver
   OK   knowledge   deriver — no episode has closed here; nothing to judge
   INFO project     .ai/repo/project — no canonical project model here; nothing to validate
   OK   projection  AGENTS.md — content matches its stamp
   OK   projection  CLAUDE.md — content matches its stamp
   OK   projection  GEMINI.md — content matches its stamp
   OK   context     builder — 21 lines, budget 300  [reproduce: majordomus context]
   OK   capture     share/schemas/majordomus/capture/capture.v1 — 2 file(s) describe majordomus.capture/v1 at the path the identifier derives: the record as JSON Schema, the document as protobuf
   OK   capture     .ai/local/prompts — ignored and untracked
   OK   capture     .ai/local/prompts — no records yet; the archive is empty
   OK   capture     .ai/local/prompts — every prompt is present as all three: the record, the Markdown and the YAML
   OK   prompts     .ai/local/prompts — the archive and every record in it are readable by their owner only
   OK   prompts     .ai/local/prompts — no records yet; the archive is empty
   OK   prompt      4 asset(s) — front matter valid, every token known
   OK   records     open-questions.md — every entry parses
   OK   retention   ledger — 2 lines, cap 5000
   OK   retention   handovers — 0 files, cap 200
   OK   retention   checkpoints — 0 files, cap 500
   OK   retention   sessions — 0 records, cap 500
   INFO project     .ai/repo/project — no canonical project model here; nothing to validate
   OK   rules       .ai/repo/rules/vendor/majordomus — every file matches the manifest (1 (1.0.0-alpha.8))
   OK   rules       61 rule(s) — resolve in one deterministic order; vendored baseline plus project rules, no override — 51 carry a validator, 10 are normative text this tool does not check
   OK   rules       blocking — all 44 blocking rule(s) carry a validator
   OK   schema      rules — 61 rule(s) resolve in one order: the vendored baseline in manifest order, then the project's, as a dependency graph
   OK   schema      share/kinds.yaml — 37 kind(s); every one that carries metadata declares a schema
   OK   schema      share/schemas — 54 schema(s), each valid JSON and each applied — by a kind, through an allow-list the tool reads, by a validator that names it, or as a generated document's contract (15)
   INFO scope       - — no active task
   OK   session     .ai/local/session-contexts — ignored and untracked
   OK   session     .ai/local/session-contexts — no working contexts yet; the store is empty
   INFO skill       .ai/repo/skills/ — no skills; nothing to validate
   OK   skill       reachable — no personal command or skill shares a name with a projected skill  [reproduce: majordomus run editors.status]
   INFO state       - — no active task
   ·    budget      watch — <timed against the policy budget>
   INFO state       - — no active task
   watch: 0 drift finding(s)

   • exit 0
   • stdout_contains /0 drift finding/

Why the tool knows this

The chain from this page to the code: the use case names commands, rules and claims; each rule is dispatched from the registry and each claim names the test that proves it; the scenario above executed the commands. Nothing in this chain is prose about intent.

• majordomus updateRegenerate every provider instruction file from the one policy, deterministically.
• majordomus doctorIt checks governance only: is Majordomus itself healthy, and is every enforcement it declares actually wired here?
• majordomus watchWhat has drifted since the last update — policy, projections, state, retention.

The rules that make it hold

• ✕blocking Bootstrap integrityThe path from a human reader to the AI layer is unbroken — README.md names AGENTS.md, every generated instruction file points at .ai/README.md, and none of them carries a rule of its own.
• ✕blocking Projection integrityEvery generated instruction file exists, matches the stamp it carries, and is never silently overwritten after a hand edit.
• ✕blocking Context budgetThe always-loaded projection stays within its line budget, every reference in it resolves, it states no count that will go stale, and the assembled context fits the builder's own budget.

Guarantees exercised

• ○guaranteed Provider instruction files are generated from the one policy, deterministically
• ○guaranteed Every generated instruction file carries its own stamp, and a hand edit is detected
• ○guaranteed A hand-edited instruction file is never silently overwritten
• ○guaranteed The always-loaded instruction file has a line budget with a failing check
• ○guaranteed Every repository-relative reference in the always-loaded file is proven to resolve
• ○guaranteed A hardcoded count in the always-loaded file is a failure
• ○guaranteed Provider instruction files are thin bootstraps that point at the AI layer and carry no rule of their own

Related use cases

Computed from what they share: claims, rules, commands, category, applications. Nobody maintains this list.

• Adopt a repository that already has its own rulesInstall the supervisory layer into a repository with a hand-written CLAUDE.md, without the tool taking ownership of a file somebody else wrote.
• Find out what has drifted since anyone last lookedAsk what has moved, rather than whether anything is wrong.
• Extend what the executable serves by adding a file, never by rebuilding itAdd a rule, a prompt or a knowledge node to .ai/ and have it appear as an MCP resource, an HTTP route and a reference entry, with the same binary.
• Say what your work is for, once, and have every surface say itRecord an operational failure mode as one file and have the command line, the API, MCP and the website answer it without registering it anywhere.
• See what the repository holds, and run one of its capabilities, without reading a fileOpen the shared server in a browser and get the whole layer as pages: what exists, where each thing came from, what depends on what, what is failing, and a form that runs any capability.

The moments this answers

• → opened CLAUDE.md and AGENTS.md and found two different rulebooks for one repository Each provider reads its own hand-edited file, nothing relates them, and which contract applies depends on which tool is open.
• → watched the always-loaded instruction file grow past a thousand lines Everything important gets appended to the always-loaded file, so every session pays for every rule and reads none of them carefully.